Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Paulie's pizza 7.6/10 (Really Good! Breanna's garlic knot meatball sliders 7.2/10 (Really Good! off the menu item idea the bartender/waitress created Maria's Meatballs 6.8/10 (Really Good! Garlic knots 4.2/10 (Okay! To keep it short, the coal fired pizza was pretty fire and had very little flop which I really enjoyed. It's made extremely well with quality ingredients and the crust was unbelievable. It was very buttery like if you're a crust lover this is the pizza place for you!!! My only knock is the sauce. I prefer pizza with a sweeter sauce and if it had that I definitely think this would've been in the 8s. I came during happy hour so the garlic knots were a little cold and didn't seem li...

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Select Italian and Plum tomatoes, fresh Wisconsin dairy mozzarella, and 900° coal-fired ovens provide the key elements to the tasty pizza here, according to the sign on the wall of the restaurant. I have to agree. But before pizza, let's talk garlic knots and salad. Buttery, soft and chewy and full of garlic, are the garlic knots. Their taste is well worth the calories (if you care about those sorts of things). The Caesar salad is all about the home-made dressing and croutons as well as the freshly grated pecorino Romano cheese. The homemade croutons add the finishing touch. The small size is large enough to share in small portions. Yes, it's good. I really enjoy the pizza here, and I think...

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Coworker ordered from here a couple weeks ago and our order got cancelled. Was a Saturday around noon. No explanation. So this place has been on my mind. Felt risky ordering from here but they came through with door dash delivery. They sent a text confirming my order and a link to watch the driver for delivery status. Delivery was pretty much on time. I tried the ricotta meatball and the sausage broccoli rabe. The meatball was my fave of the two. The white pizza went the fastest and the bbq pizza went the slowest among the employees here. Sauce was traditional. Crust was chewy as expected. Pretty good! Each pizza 22.99-24.99 which is a lot for pizza in my opinion. But it was definitely worth...

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Fresh, hot pizza. It was good but in my opinion, it could use a little more salt. The service was friendly. I ordered on GrubHub and picked it up myself. I would like to eat here again. I'd like to dine in.

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Never disappointed their food and service! Dave, the manager, went the extra mile to ensure that our experience was nothing short of exceptional.

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten