Fire Island Rustic Bakeshop

I've come here a couple times, first for their classic croissant, the second for the pain au chocolat. Although I'm no expert and it could very well supposed to be that way, I wish the pain au chocolat had more chocolate. I got maybe 10 very small pieces (no larger than a couple chocolate chips, if that) of chocolate just in the bottom of the croissant and that was it. But the croissant was BEAUTIFUL! The exterior was a beautiful golden brown with a slight crunch, the interior was a soft, buttery, flakey texture that melts in your mouth. Truly impressive! The male taking our order was very upbeat and optimistic, which made the whole experience wonderful! I'd come again!

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

The sourdough bread may have been the best I have had and I have tried several different bakeries. The scones and croissants were on point, big time. The egg sandwiches were delicious! The service was outstanding. A very kind and helpful woman served us as we ordered a ton of stuff. She patient and super helpful. The ambiance would be hard to beat.

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Solid bakery and brunch spot! This was our second time eating here, ordering the coffee next door and their baked goods. Highly recommend their berry scones. The soup today was a little salty than I would like, but overall a solid place to grab a bite. The cost is a tad high at $13 for the soup and $16 for the sandwich.

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Epic baked goods and delicious soup too. A perfect atmosphere that was open on Mother's Day. I love the attached shops as well including the garden shop with a barrista, wine shop, and grocery store. I could just live there!

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten

Quick stop to grab a sandwich for lunch. One sandwich $16 Two cupcakes for kids $14 Total $30, tip not included. I'd be poor if I ate there every week. Only going back for bread or baguettes now.

• Nützlich
• Nicht nützlich
• Antworten