I had the most disappointing BLT I've ever had, which is surprising given how simple the sandwich should be. My husband ordered it for me with extra crispy bacon, but the tomatoes were old and mushy, almost like tomato purée, and the bacon wasn’t cooked properly. The entire sandwich was a mess and inedible. Since my husband picked it up, I didn’t know the deli’s name to complain. The next day, when he asked if I wanted another sandwich from there, I told him it was absolutely terrible. He called to speak to the manager, but she was just as disappointing as the sandwich. We shared our concerns, and she insisted their tomatoes are cut fresh every morning. She then put me on hold for two minute...
This review is from when the restaurant was still linked to 'The Garage' brand. I assume they ended that partnership due to low quality. Since they rebranded, the original review disappeared, so I’m reposting it to warn others. I come here often because it’s a quick drive from work and the food is generally good. However, the service is absolutely terrible. It’s usually very busy during rush hour, which is understandable, but the way they handle it is unacceptable. On two separate occasions, I ordered a panini and they never informed the grill cook to prepare it. I waited twenty minutes before mentioning my order, only to find out they hadn’t even started making it. I was met with apologies...
The customer service is disappointing; everyone seems to be in a rush. If you're waiting in line and someone they know arrives, they will skip over you to serve them instead. You often feel like you're bothering them just by being there. As for the food, it's just average. I definitely wouldn't recommend this place.
12 bucks for a microwaved sandwich, nice people but I got a chicken blt w Mayo and I watched the guy put it in the microwave for a minute. Very confused because if I wanted a soggy sandwich I'd go dumpster diving
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
I truly enjoy the Foodie Shack! They have creative specials that change frequently, and their soups and salads are amazing. The service is also top-notch. It’s definitely among the best delis on Long Island.
The food is out of this world. The staff is quick and friendly. The hot table is always packed with a great variety. I have worked at deli’s since 1980. These people get it right every day.
I ordered a BLT on a hero roll, and they were very generous with the bacon. Overall, the sandwich was really tasty. The price seemed fair, especially given the current inflation.
The sandwiches are made to order and they excel in what they do. I'm not a regular customer, but whenever I'm on that side of the island, this is my go-to place.
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
Food is fine but service is lacking. Sandwich/Coffee 7.57 one day and 8.11 the next. When asked why no explanation given. (Not an inflation issue).
Absolutely love this place! The food is amazing and they have such a great crew! Top Notch! :
