My partner and I have lived near this restaurant for the past 4 years, and we always talked about trying it out. Finally, on 2/27, we decided to celebrate my partner's birthday there. The ambience, service, and food were all outstanding - a solid 10/10. This restaurant exceeded our expectations. Tony himself went to every table to ensure that everyone was enjoying their meal and experience. Our waitress was extremely kind and sweet. The meatballs were the best I've ever had. We will definitely be returning!
The past couple times we have been here, it’s been disappointing. But it had been awhile, so we decided to try again. The food was bland and seemed like it had been reheated (parts of the ravioli were cold, sauce that looked like it had been sitting for awhile, etc). Tony’s used to be fantastic, especially at the price point, but this was one of the worst meals I’ve had in awhile. I’m not sure how you can make Italian food that bland and watery. Very disappointing.
Dined on New Year’s Eve. Our waiter was Jeff and he was outstanding. Gave great dinner as well as wine recommendations. I highly recommend the Chicken Marsala. Probably the best I have had anywhere. My wife ordered the sausage with peppers and onions over linguini and enjoyed that as well. Pricing is moderate. This was our first time dining here but will definitely go back.
I have been dining at this restaurant for 40 years. It is always good, Tony maintains a classic old-school vibe. It's great to see younger adults come in and be impressed by the restaurant! My wife and I always come back because it is the best Italian restaurant in Columbus. My only suggestion would be to update the bar menu and add a few modern options.
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
We love going to Tony's. Enjoy the food and atmosphere. We were there for our anniversary last week. Everything was great. Unfortunately, there was a large group seated near us, someone pitching health insurance to the group. Kind of took the whole romantic anniversary dinner vibe down a couple notches.
We hadn’t been to Tony’s in quite some time not sure why. Nice to see Tony working the room. Great food and real good service. We will be back. Parking on site a plus!
Great atmosphere. Decent food. The drinks were really bad. For sure I get they are good price, but espresso martini tasted like water without any vodka or coffee
Will be going back next time we crave Italian food. Price was not too bad compared to the quality of the food. 10/10. Would recommend going there for a date
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
The martini was only half full when it was served to me and the food was terrible.
really enjoyed new years dinner here as we always do, can’t go wrong with Tony’s.
Veal Piccata (Light, Not Too Filling)
Insalata De Pesce (Seafood Saldad)
Homemade Carrot Cake With Raisins
Anitaâ Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Alla Casino Linguini (Sausage)
Tony's Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Ameretto Chocolate Cheesecake
Spinach And Cheese Cannelloni
Veal And Prosciutto Capellini
Hausgemachter Karottenkuchen
