My wife and I are super fans of oysters and seafood, so when our AirBNB host highly recommended this place as her personal local favorite, it did not disappoint! We indulged in dozen+half oysters (our favorites were the peconic gold and mermaid makeout), their award-winning clam chowder, fried oysters on the rocks, margaritas, and the local IPA. Three standout points: firstly, the award-winning chowder truly deserves all its accolades; secondly, the oysters were the freshest and most delicious we've ever had in our 30 years on this rock; and lastly, Long Island doesn't skimp out on their alcohol--my wife's cocktails were potent! A double thumbs-up from my wife and myself; I'm fully on board...
Catch is always lively, attracting a fun crowd, and it’s easy to see why. The food is outstanding, especially if you're a seafood enthusiast—this place is a must-visit! While the atmosphere is cozy and pub-like, that just adds to its charm. It has a welcoming "Cheers" vibe, but with superb cuisine. My favorite appetizer is the roasted oysters, though the tuna poke bowl is also incredible! On Friday, we indulged in the seared tuna special, which came with risotto and charred asparagus. The lemon butter caper sauce on that dish was absolutely delicious. We also tried the warm lobster roll, which was buttery, tender, and full of flavor. Make your way to Catch, enjoy some delectable seafood, and...
As for the main courses, we had a mix of experiences. The Lobster Roll was somewhat disappointing, lacking in flavor. On the bright side, it was accompanied by delicious fries and decent coleslaw. The Blackened Fish Tacos were also mild and didn't pack the expected punch, while the Shrimp Po Boy had potential but was unfortunately overcooked.
In summary, Catch Oyster Bar has a lovely ambiance, a friendly server, and offers quick service. Although some of the dishes fell short in the flavor department, the overall experience was positive largely due to the attentive service.
I had a fantastic experience at this restaurant, thanks to the fast and friendly service and the incredibly fresh seafood! I dined in and found the atmosphere to be delightful. For about $20–30 per person, the food was outstanding, earning a solid 5 out of 5. The service was equally impressive, also a perfect 5, and the ambiance was just right, deserving another 5. I highly recommend trying the Oysters on the Half Shell—they're always fresh and delicious! They also have a great bar and the chowder is a must-try.
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
Catch did an outdoor party for us. They arrived on time, set up a beautiful spread, cleaned up, and the food was absolutely delicious. Their party coordinator, Maisie, was extremely accommodating and great to work with. Thank you, Catch! Meal type: Other Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Excellent Food , Always fresh , Wonderful staff ,,, Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Recommended dishes: Oysters on the Half Shell Always Fresh and Delish Great Bar Too, Roll Parking space: Plenty of parking Parking options: Free parking lot
It's a cozy little spot that is always bustling with customers. The seafood is fantastic and incredibly fresh! The owner is very friendly, and the service is excellent!
**Service:** Dine-in
**Meal Type:** Dinner
**Price per Person:** $20–30
**Food Rating:** 5/5
**Service Rating:** 5/5
**Atmosphere Rating:** 5/5
Reserviere jetzt einen Tisch
Quick and fresh fish tacos! Their fish tacos have always been a favorite of mine. I especially love them blackened. A bonus is that they are gluten-free!
Service: Dine-in
Meal type: Lunch
Price per person: $20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes: Clams, Fish Tacos
Buttermilk Ranch Fried Chicken
In Sesam Gebratener Thunfisch
Garnelenmuscheln Fra Diavolo
Catch Signature Lobster Roll
Geschwärzter Thunfisch-Wrap
Char Grilled Octopus Salad
